We Spoke to Is This a 3D Model? About AI, 3D Modeling & The Goal of Their Twitter Page
Could you please share a few words about yourself and your artistic background?Is This a 3D Model?: I think the best word to describe myself is "Teapot," because that is what I am, but I'd also say I'm a "3D model lover," because I am also that.I am a self-taught professional 3D Artist, and I am most proficient in ZBrush and 3ds Max.
Have I mentioned I love 3D models? I just think they're so neat!Back when the so-called "AI-boom" kicked off in mid-2022, many artists were initially optimistic about the concept, what was your reaction when the first text-to-image AIs started popping up?Is This a 3D Model?: My first reaction to the "AI-boom" was, "These are not 3D models, so who even cares?" But I tried many tools such as Midjourney, Stable Diffusion, DALL-E, and was consistently underwhelmed by the results.
I found much better inspiration and ideas by looking up artists' work online.
I've tried many times to "adapt AI into my workflow," but I often found it made my workflow worse, both quality and productivity-wise.
So now I call it out for what it is – stinky!Were you among those whose opinion on generative artificial intelligence changed over time, or were you anti-AI from the beginning? When would you say most creators started to recognize the unfair practices and overall shady behavior of AI companies and their language models?Is This a 3D Model?: I always hated how companies collected people's work without permission, and I always laughed at AI bros who pretended to be fine artists because they typed a prompt! But in the beginning, I thought the tech had more promise and potential.As time went on, I tried it more and didn't see much value in it.
To this day, there is very little it can actually help me with (and I still try).
I also observed many instances of shady behavior from AI companies, they act very sus on Twitter.
And can you believe, some of these gen-3D companies have the nerve to call a model "high quality" when it looks terrible? Like, c'mon man, have you looked at a 3D model at any point in the last few years? Totally embarrassing!I might be mistaken here, but I think the first instance of mass protests against AI took place in December 2022 with the "Say No to AI Images" movement on ArtStation.
What were your thoughts as that protest unfolded? In your opinion, are such online campaigns effective or not?Is This a 3D Model?: I thought the protest was rad! I even uploaded a "No AI" Image on my personal portfolio when it happened.
I don't know if banning AI entirely will ever be possible, but ArtStation was being a total butt and could have done a better job allowing users to filter AI out or report people who are misrepresenting their skill sets.
It is a professional portfolio site after all.Let's talk about Is This a 3D Model?, when was the page created? What first inspired you to start it? What goal do you ultimately want to achieve with your work?Is This a 3D Model?: This Twitter page started as a joke about a year ago.
Whenever I would post negative comments on AI on my main 3D art account, AI bros would show up in my comments with some weird Midjourney images and try to tell me "give up, bro, it's over for you!" However, because AI bros don't know much about art, technology, or, well, anything, I would politely inform them that what they posted was not a 3D model.Over time, this became very frequent for people to post "3D modeling workflows of the future," where the final result was not a 3D model.
I decided someone needed to take a stand for all the poor, defenseless 3D models out there!As the page grew, I decided I wanted to use it more to highlight the great work 3D Artists are doing and trying to make more "yes" posts than "no" posts.
I hope to call out a lot more of these bad workflows that AI accounts are trying to promote as "the future" and encourage more 3D Artists to stay on the course and learn valuable skills.
There are a lot of forces discouraging people from creating art these days.
But I truly think genAI is not as capable as it's being made out to be, and all this does is prevent more people from discovering the joy of creation.
And that is lame!How do you make sure you're answering the "Is this a 3D model?" question correctly for dozens of projects each week?Is This a 3D Model?: It's actually a lot easier than you think in most cases! I usually check the source, if the poster has an art portfolio, pretty safe bet it's a 3D model – AI bros don't have art portfolios.
Also, when you've looked at 3D work for a long time, sometimes you can just develop the eye and tell! Can you see the faceted edges around the shape? Does it look suspiciously overly polished with no attention to literally any details? Are they calling it 3D but posting a Midjourney SREF? I think some of the ones I've classified that are the most surprising are ones that try to create the vibe of N64 games, and I suspect people are either too young to know what N64 games actually look like or just forgot.Based on your experience running the Is This a 3D Model? page, could you please share a brief guide our readers can use to confidently tell whether a given project is truly 3D? What specific signs should we look out for to be sure?Is This a 3D Model?: We implement something called the SIP method (Get it? Like sipping tea? I didn't just make this up for this interview, I promise):Source: Who is posting it? Do they look like a 3D Artist? Do they have a portfolio? Or do they mostly post Midjourney images or 3-second video clips of people talking with robot voices and explosions?Investigate: Look at the image! Can you see weird AI artifacts that make no sense? Can you see faceted edges? Does it look like a consistent 3D model with a well-executed idea?Polygons: If all else fails, can you find a screenshot of the topology? It won't exist with AI images.
And if you can, does it make any sense? Some people even make fake wireframes with AI, I've attached a great example of that below.
While this may look like a 3D wireframe, if you look closely, the details don't make sense.
Why is a simple cylindrical cup so messy? Why do the trucks on the shirt turn into a drawing? It's all because an AI Image generator made a JPG of a wireframe.
How silly!Usually, using one or all of these techniques, you can determine pretty quickly if what you're looking at is a safe, lovely 3D model or gross, yucky AI.Regarding the digital art industry as a whole, who would you say are the worst offenders – be it AI developers, companies, individuals, art platforms, you name it – on the matter of AI?Is This a 3D Model?: A lot of companies have sadly succumbed to the AI fad, be it fearmongering or overhyping.
The worst offenders by far are the companies developing these AI products.
They often don't even pretend to be professional companies and do all sorts of weird things.
There is one generative 3D company where the owner resorts to posting fake endorsement comments all over Reddit.
Embarassing!The second worst are all the grifters on Twitter who just post "Hollywood is Dead Part 85" over and over again.
If AI is so good, you all wouldn't need to post so much slop! For the Is This a 3D Model family personally, I have to say one of the biggest offenders is some guy who compared our account to nazis because I said "no" on one of their posts.
Wild!AI is, unfortunately, everywhere, but artists are also everywhere.
Seek out the many talented 2D and 3D Artists on all the platforms and fill your feed with them! The majority of artists don't use AI and for a good reason.
Pretty soon, your feed will be full of lovely art and 3D models, and you'll have brief moments where you forget AI slop even exists!Lastly, what are your hopes for digital art going forward? How do you think the industry will look in, let's say, 5-10 years? What can we all do to combat the spread of generative AI?Is This a 3D Model?: I would like to end this on a message of hope.
While a lot of jobs will be impacted in the short term, I think in 5-10 years, the limitations of AI tools will be much more well-known than they are today.
I also think AI will plateau at a certain look and style that people are already getting sick of today.
A lot of companies that rudely get rid of artists will quickly realize they got scammed by AI companies, and they still need those artists because AI will fall short in many ways.
Plus, many companies simply won't want their video games or their commercials to look like the weird slop plaguing Facebook.The best thing we can do moving forward is to keep focusing on the skills that matter.
Learn art fundamentals, drawing, sculpting, anatomy, color theory, and, of course, 3D modeling! Don't listen to "adapt or get left behind!" AI tools are designed for babies! If you spend your time grinding your art skills and developing your artistic eye, even if you are one day forced to use AI tools, you will be the most qualified to use them.
Does anyone really think in 5-10 years, "prompt engineering skills" will still exist? Puh-LEASE.
Using an AI is already as easy as googling, and it will just get easier.
People will always want people who are competent and know what they're doing, and the best way you can do that is by showing you've got your own skills!Art is a historically challenging field for anyone.
It always has been! The only way you'll make it is by working hard at it, challenging yourself, and not letting yourself get discouraged.
I always recommend people to have backup plans and figure out what a viable career path is.
This was important even before AI.I was one of those people who gave up on art jobs, I never thought I'd have one.
Thought it was too competitive and focused on a different career entirely.
But I kept doing 3D as a hobby because I LOVE POLYGONS.
I would dedicate time every night to work in ZBrush for fun, and now I'm a professional 3D Artist! Part of why I run this account is that I know what it's like to be discouraged from pursuing art.
And I know if I ever extinguished that flame, I wouldn't be living my dream right now.
I hope one day in 5-10 years someone reading this today can say this motivated them to put in the time and effort to become an incredible artist, despite all the naysayers, and got one of those jobs that supposedly wasn't going to exist anymore!Is This a 3D Model, 3D ArtistInterview conducted by Theodore McKenzie
Source: https://80.lv/articles/we-spoke-to-is-this-a-3d-model-about-ai-3d-modeling-the-goal-of-their-twitter-page/" style="color: #0066cc;">https://80.lv/articles/we-spoke-to-is-this-a-3d-model-about-ai-3d-modeling-the-goal-of-their-twitter-page/
#spoke #this #model #about #modeling #ampamp #the #goal #their #twitter #page
We Spoke to Is This a 3D Model? About AI, 3D Modeling & The Goal of Their Twitter Page
Could you please share a few words about yourself and your artistic background?Is This a 3D Model?: I think the best word to describe myself is "Teapot," because that is what I am, but I'd also say I'm a "3D model lover," because I am also that.
I am a self-taught professional 3D Artist, and I am most proficient in ZBrush and 3ds Max.
Have I mentioned I love 3D models? I just think they're so neat!Back when the so-called "AI-boom" kicked off in mid-2022, many artists were initially optimistic about the concept, what was your reaction when the first text-to-image AIs started popping up?Is This a 3D Model?: My first reaction to the "AI-boom" was, "These are not 3D models, so who even cares?" But I tried many tools such as Midjourney, Stable Diffusion, DALL-E, and was consistently underwhelmed by the results.
I found much better inspiration and ideas by looking up artists' work online.
I've tried many times to "adapt AI into my workflow," but I often found it made my workflow worse, both quality and productivity-wise.
So now I call it out for what it is – stinky!Were you among those whose opinion on generative artificial intelligence changed over time, or were you anti-AI from the beginning? When would you say most creators started to recognize the unfair practices and overall shady behavior of AI companies and their language models?Is This a 3D Model?: I always hated how companies collected people's work without permission, and I always laughed at AI bros who pretended to be fine artists because they typed a prompt! But in the beginning, I thought the tech had more promise and potential.As time went on, I tried it more and didn't see much value in it.
To this day, there is very little it can actually help me with (and I still try).
I also observed many instances of shady behavior from AI companies, they act very sus on Twitter.
And can you believe, some of these gen-3D companies have the nerve to call a model "high quality" when it looks terrible? Like, c'mon man, have you looked at a 3D model at any point in the last few years? Totally embarrassing!I might be mistaken here, but I think the first instance of mass protests against AI took place in December 2022 with the "Say No to AI Images" movement on ArtStation.
What were your thoughts as that protest unfolded? In your opinion, are such online campaigns effective or not?Is This a 3D Model?: I thought the protest was rad! I even uploaded a "No AI" Image on my personal portfolio when it happened.
I don't know if banning AI entirely will ever be possible, but ArtStation was being a total butt and could have done a better job allowing users to filter AI out or report people who are misrepresenting their skill sets.
It is a professional portfolio site after all.Let's talk about Is This a 3D Model?, when was the page created? What first inspired you to start it? What goal do you ultimately want to achieve with your work?Is This a 3D Model?: This Twitter page started as a joke about a year ago.
Whenever I would post negative comments on AI on my main 3D art account, AI bros would show up in my comments with some weird Midjourney images and try to tell me "give up, bro, it's over for you!" However, because AI bros don't know much about art, technology, or, well, anything, I would politely inform them that what they posted was not a 3D model.Over time, this became very frequent for people to post "3D modeling workflows of the future," where the final result was not a 3D model.
I decided someone needed to take a stand for all the poor, defenseless 3D models out there!As the page grew, I decided I wanted to use it more to highlight the great work 3D Artists are doing and trying to make more "yes" posts than "no" posts.
I hope to call out a lot more of these bad workflows that AI accounts are trying to promote as "the future" and encourage more 3D Artists to stay on the course and learn valuable skills.
There are a lot of forces discouraging people from creating art these days.
But I truly think genAI is not as capable as it's being made out to be, and all this does is prevent more people from discovering the joy of creation.
And that is lame!How do you make sure you're answering the "Is this a 3D model?" question correctly for dozens of projects each week?Is This a 3D Model?: It's actually a lot easier than you think in most cases! I usually check the source, if the poster has an art portfolio, pretty safe bet it's a 3D model – AI bros don't have art portfolios.
Also, when you've looked at 3D work for a long time, sometimes you can just develop the eye and tell! Can you see the faceted edges around the shape? Does it look suspiciously overly polished with no attention to literally any details? Are they calling it 3D but posting a Midjourney SREF? I think some of the ones I've classified that are the most surprising are ones that try to create the vibe of N64 games, and I suspect people are either too young to know what N64 games actually look like or just forgot.Based on your experience running the Is This a 3D Model? page, could you please share a brief guide our readers can use to confidently tell whether a given project is truly 3D? What specific signs should we look out for to be sure?Is This a 3D Model?: We implement something called the SIP method (Get it? Like sipping tea? I didn't just make this up for this interview, I promise):Source: Who is posting it? Do they look like a 3D Artist? Do they have a portfolio? Or do they mostly post Midjourney images or 3-second video clips of people talking with robot voices and explosions?Investigate: Look at the image! Can you see weird AI artifacts that make no sense? Can you see faceted edges? Does it look like a consistent 3D model with a well-executed idea?Polygons: If all else fails, can you find a screenshot of the topology? It won't exist with AI images.
And if you can, does it make any sense? Some people even make fake wireframes with AI, I've attached a great example of that below.
While this may look like a 3D wireframe, if you look closely, the details don't make sense.
Why is a simple cylindrical cup so messy? Why do the trucks on the shirt turn into a drawing? It's all because an AI Image generator made a JPG of a wireframe.
How silly!Usually, using one or all of these techniques, you can determine pretty quickly if what you're looking at is a safe, lovely 3D model or gross, yucky AI.Regarding the digital art industry as a whole, who would you say are the worst offenders – be it AI developers, companies, individuals, art platforms, you name it – on the matter of AI?Is This a 3D Model?: A lot of companies have sadly succumbed to the AI fad, be it fearmongering or overhyping.
The worst offenders by far are the companies developing these AI products.
They often don't even pretend to be professional companies and do all sorts of weird things.
There is one generative 3D company where the owner resorts to posting fake endorsement comments all over Reddit.
Embarassing!The second worst are all the grifters on Twitter who just post "Hollywood is Dead Part 85" over and over again.
If AI is so good, you all wouldn't need to post so much slop! For the Is This a 3D Model family personally, I have to say one of the biggest offenders is some guy who compared our account to nazis because I said "no" on one of their posts.
Wild!AI is, unfortunately, everywhere, but artists are also everywhere.
Seek out the many talented 2D and 3D Artists on all the platforms and fill your feed with them! The majority of artists don't use AI and for a good reason.
Pretty soon, your feed will be full of lovely art and 3D models, and you'll have brief moments where you forget AI slop even exists!Lastly, what are your hopes for digital art going forward? How do you think the industry will look in, let's say, 5-10 years? What can we all do to combat the spread of generative AI?Is This a 3D Model?: I would like to end this on a message of hope.
While a lot of jobs will be impacted in the short term, I think in 5-10 years, the limitations of AI tools will be much more well-known than they are today.
I also think AI will plateau at a certain look and style that people are already getting sick of today.
A lot of companies that rudely get rid of artists will quickly realize they got scammed by AI companies, and they still need those artists because AI will fall short in many ways.
Plus, many companies simply won't want their video games or their commercials to look like the weird slop plaguing Facebook.The best thing we can do moving forward is to keep focusing on the skills that matter.
Learn art fundamentals, drawing, sculpting, anatomy, color theory, and, of course, 3D modeling! Don't listen to "adapt or get left behind!" AI tools are designed for babies! If you spend your time grinding your art skills and developing your artistic eye, even if you are one day forced to use AI tools, you will be the most qualified to use them.
Does anyone really think in 5-10 years, "prompt engineering skills" will still exist? Puh-LEASE.
Using an AI is already as easy as googling, and it will just get easier.
People will always want people who are competent and know what they're doing, and the best way you can do that is by showing you've got your own skills!Art is a historically challenging field for anyone.
It always has been! The only way you'll make it is by working hard at it, challenging yourself, and not letting yourself get discouraged.
I always recommend people to have backup plans and figure out what a viable career path is.
This was important even before AI.I was one of those people who gave up on art jobs, I never thought I'd have one.
Thought it was too competitive and focused on a different career entirely.
But I kept doing 3D as a hobby because I LOVE POLYGONS.
I would dedicate time every night to work in ZBrush for fun, and now I'm a professional 3D Artist! Part of why I run this account is that I know what it's like to be discouraged from pursuing art.
And I know if I ever extinguished that flame, I wouldn't be living my dream right now.
I hope one day in 5-10 years someone reading this today can say this motivated them to put in the time and effort to become an incredible artist, despite all the naysayers, and got one of those jobs that supposedly wasn't going to exist anymore!Is This a 3D Model, 3D ArtistInterview conducted by Theodore McKenzie
Source: https://80.lv/articles/we-spoke-to-is-this-a-3d-model-about-ai-3d-modeling-the-goal-of-their-twitter-page/
#spoke #this #model #about #modeling #ampamp #the #goal #their #twitter #page
·4 Views