February 20, 20255 min readSurprising Chimpanzee Signal Reveals Secrets of Ape CommunicationA rare and deliberate signal between a mother chimpanzee and her daughter raises new questions about ape communication, culture and the meaning of sharing a languageBy Avery Schuyler Nunn edited by Sarah Lewin FrasierA mother chimpanzee, Beryl, sits by her infant, Lindsay, in a remote forest in Uganda. Kevin C. LeeAn hours drive down a ragged dirt road, deep in the heart of Ugandas Kibale National Park, a small research camp sits in the middle of chimpanzee territory. Tangled vines drape ancient trees in the semi deciduous forest, and equatorial sunsets ignite the sky, savannas, lakes and misty mountain peaks in molten gold and ember red. For the primatologists stationed here, mornings begin with a map of yesterdays chimp movements, a tally of fruiting treesand an ear tuned to the forest. The apes calls start early with low, rolling pant-hoots that ripple through the canopy. On some days the chimps are close by. On others the researchers search for them for hours, winding through the Ngogo chimpanzee communitys home range of 35 square kilometers (an area about half the size of Manhattan), on a grid of well-worn trails.On one such morning in 2019, a few researchers spotted something curious: Lindsay, a chimpanzee around two years old, reached forward from her mother Beryls back to cover the older chimps only eye. At first, it seemed like a fleeting moment of play. But the scientists would later learn that Beryl, who moved attentively through the undergrowth with occasional pauses, responded the same way each timeby stepping forward. Within a few years, the gesture had clearly become an intentional lets get moving! signal. Again and again, she would lay her fingers over Beryls eye; each time, her mother would move forward.Chimpanzee Beryl and her infant, Lindsay, perform their hand-on-eye gesture.Kevin C. LeeOn supporting science journalismIf you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.What may have started as Lindsays simple, spontaneous attempt to get her mothers attentionby blocking Beryls already limited visionbecame a ritualized and regularly used signal, a form of shared meaning akin to a secret handshake or inside joke. Among the Ngogo chimpanzees, researchers are coming to realize that such behaviors arent random quirks but part of a growing picture of how apes develop and transmit culture.This is fascinating from a [scientific] literature perspective because there had been no prior record of this gesture, says Bas van Boekholt, a primatologist now at the University of Zurich, who led a recent study in Animal Cognition to decipher the actions meaning. During his second field season at Ngogo in 2022, van Boekholt was reviewing video footage from his field assistant when he first noticed Lindsays hand-on-eye behavior. Among nonhuman primates, previous examples of gestures that were unique to particular individuals had only been documented in captive environments, he says. We havent had convincing evidence that they occur in the wild, van Boekholt adds.Lindsay covers Beryls eye.Bas van BoekholtCurious whether others had observed Lindsay making the same gesture, van Boekholt reached out to fellow researchers and field assistants. Isabelle Clark, a biological anthropologist at the University of Texas at Austin, recalled being among those who spotted the behavior as early as 2019. This is a big deal because this gesture isnt part of the common chimp repertoire. Its not in our chimp gesture dictionary, so to speak, she explains. Its a rare and compelling example of how gestures might be learned rather than hardwired. Im sure there are subtle, unrecorded ones between closely bonded individuals, but this one stood out; it was so striking and even a little funny.To investigate further, researchers from various field seasons conducted a collaborative quantitative analysis of 179 videos of Lindsay and Beryl that included 21 instances in which Lindsay used the gesture. Young chimps are known to be playful while riding on their mothers back, so the scientists scrutinized Lindsays behavior for markers of intentionality. Was she simply brushing her mothers eye by accident? The data suggested otherwise.Van Boekholts team also reviewed more than 1,020 video clips of 12 other mother-child pairs within the Ngogo community and found no evidence of the gesture occurring among themexcept for three isolated instances in which other chimps performed it just once, without the same intentionality markers present in Lindsay and Beryls interactions.Infants do play around on their mothers backs and sometimes touch their mothers eyes, but its different; theres no clear intent or consistent outcome, van Boekholt says. Maybe if we analyzed another 1,200 clips, wed find more cases, but at this point, we feel confident in saying this is an idiosyncratic gesture.Chimpanzees Lindsay and her mother, Beryl, in 2019.Kevin C. LeeClark, who specializes in social behavior development in juvenile and adolescent chimpanzees, says that chimps exhibit foundational elements of symbolic communicationhumans ability to create limitless symbols for different meaningsand that gestures like Lindsays could be the building blocks of eventual humanlike communication.There are multiple theories on how gestures develop in primates, particularly great apes, van Boekholt says. Tracking their development over a lifetime offers clues about the evolution of language and communication.The researchers note that if the hand-on-eye gesture exists in other chimpanzee communities, it likely carries a different meaning there. Cat Hobaiter, a primatologist and a field scientist, who was not involved in the study, cautions against drawing broad conclusions from a single chimpanzee group. Its like trying to describe human civilization after only visiting Paris, Shanghai, and Auckland, she says. Just as customs and traditions differ across human cultures, gestures among chimpanzees can vary widely; a signal of reassurance in one group might mean something entirely different, or nothing at all, in another.For instance, the long-recognized and well-documented gesture of leaf clippingin which a chimpanzee tears a leaf with its teethvaries in meaning across chimp communities. In some groups, leaf clippings distinctive sound serves as a mating call, while in others, it signals frustration or an alpha males display of dominance.Ape communication researchers have long debated whether gestures and signals such as these are innate or learned through social context and experience. Many scientists now recognize that while gestures may have biological roots, their meanings are shaped by social and environmental dynamics.Beryl and Lindsay on the move.Kevin C. LeeThe development of Lindsays gesture, Hobaiter explains, suggests that apeslike humanshave the capacity to form particular shared uses of a signal. It doesnt necessarily mean that it was created by them from scratch, she says. For instance, a baby chimp could see a gesture in another context and adapt it to have a new meaning.Hobaiter cautions against overemphasizing uniqueness at the expense of a broader insight: the more we observe, the more depth we see in ape cultures. Chimpanzees and bonobos share nearly 99 percent of their DNA with humans. And their traditions, social learning and communication reveal a continuum rather than a sharp divide between us and other great apes.Van Boekholt has returned to Uganda, where he is once again studying the mother-daughter duo. Lindsay, who is old enough to walk independently, still clings to her motherand continues to use the gesture. Van Boekholt suspects Beryl may be pregnant, and he is eager to see whether Lindsays potential future sibling will adopt the gesture and thus turn it into a family tradition. If social learning plays a role, he notes, the gesture is likely to persist. Any parent of a newborn understands the private language they share with their childmeanings that others would never recognize. Now were seeing a similar phenomenon unfold in the wild, he explains. For Lindsay, logically, blocking her mothers vision seems counterintuitive, the last thing shed want to do. Yet, for some reason, [Lindsay and Beryl have] created this shared meaning between them, and I think thats just really wonderful.Lindsay covers Beryl's eye.Kevin C. Lee