WWW.THEVERGE.COM
How close is Elon Musk to controlling a nuclear weapon?
What was once ridiculous is now possible. Elon Musk, the richest person in the history of the world, has become President Donald Trumps attack dog. Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) have unprecedented access to the governments data and computer system. Earlier this week, that came to include systems in the Department of Energy (DOE), which oversees Americas nuclear weapons. The news raised enough concern that Secretary of Energy Chris Wright went on the air to deny Musk and DOGE have access to atomic secrets.Its alarming to be at a point where someone has to make this kind of statement, especially because the Trump administration has reportedly lied about DOGEs access levels before. DOGEs placement at the DOE even raises a truly bizarre-sounding possibility: that a pseudo-department named after a shiba inu could get actual access to nuclear weapons. Fortunately, despite Musks ever-expanding power over government systems, it would take far more than barging into the right office to do this. But at a moment where all kinds of governmental norms are in flux, its worth looking at what exactly separates someone like Musk from perhaps the greatest destructive force on the planet and what other kinds of risks his access could pose.The US has one of the most powerful nuclear arsenals on the planet. Its enough firepower to end all life on Earth several times over. The President has the sole authority to launch those weapons, but DOGE is inching ever closer to their systems. During a press conference on Friday, Trump said he had directed Musk and DOGE to tackle spending at the Pentagon; getting access to the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) might not be out of the question either. Theres good news, however: accessing any piece of nuclear command and control from a random laptop hooked into a DOE network is virtually impossible. A State Department employee with knowledge of the issue, who spoke to The Verge on the condition we protect their anonymity, threw cold water on the idea.I cant see what [Musk] would possibly do, the employee said. I would say its zero. I cant fathom how that would happen. Famous last words. I also firmly believe that if you make something idiot proof, the world will build a better idiot. Launching a nuke requires physical access to the weapon itself. Missileers have to turn keys. A submarine crew must prep and fire a missile. A bomber crew must pull levers and hone in on targets. Short of Musk or his employees entering a silo, climbing onto a stealth bomber, or getting into a submarine, its not going to happen.I cant fathom how that would happen. Famous last words.The command and control systems that run Americas nuclear weapons arent connected to the internet and are run on a closed network that exists only for nuclear forces. Theyre also ancient. Some of the equipment in use has been around since the 1960s and 70s. The Pentagon is modernizing the systems, but its slow going. The Air Force only stopped using 1970s-era eight-inch floppy discs for some of its nuclear computers in 2019. A lot of these computer systems are pretty much legacy systems, the employee said. Im much more worried about these systems being decrepit and not functioning in a crisis. Theres a misconception rooted in popular culture that Americas nuclear weapons will fire if the U.S. is ever fired upon. If China, Russia, or North Korea were to fire a nuke at the U.S., Americas nukes would not automatically fire. The President would need to decide to retaliate and multiple military officials would have to decide to follow the order. Those systems are not really automated in the way that people worry about, the State Department employee said.Alex Wellerstein, an associate professor at the Stevens Institute of Technology and an expert in nukes and nuclear secrecy, agreed. I dont think the current command and control systems are hackable, he told The Verge. They are frankly not modern enough for that.Wallerstein points out, however, that Musk has another arguably more feasible path to nuclear weapons: Trump. If Musk was trying to do a true hostile takeover of that sort it would be best accomplished by just fooling Trump into believing nuclear war was imminent, which would probably be a trivial endeavor for someone of Musks wealth and Trumps gullibility, he said.For this to happen, Trump would need to open up his Football: a leather-coated Zero Halliburton aluminum attache case that follows the president everywhere. Inside is communications equipment that puts him in touch with the National Military Command Center at the Pentagon. To make the call, Trump would need a laminated sheet of paper called the Biscuit, containing a long string of alpha-numeric code. Hes supposed to have this with him at all times too. Reading out a line in this code, which the National Security Agency updates every day, confirms the Presidents identity when he calls in a nuclear strike. The President doesnt have launch codes. The President has a code that authenticates his voice, the State Department Employee said.So Musk would have to get the Biscuit, access the Football, and call in a code in Trumps voice. Or convince Trump to do it. Short of something like that, I dont think theres a chance, the State Department employee said.But theres one final, worrying wrinkle: the Football and the Biscuit only exist because people in the past decided its the best way for the President to order a nuclear launch. Trump could change this process at any time for any reason. There are also many quite detailed regulations pertaining to who can have access to the systems involving the use of nuclear weapons, with specific requirements for clearances and reliability and so on, Wellerstein said. These are all essentially executive regulations, and the President is capable of delegating nuclear use powers, and past Presidents have certainly done that, essentially pre-authorizing the use of nuclear weapons by the military under specific circumstances.President Eisenhower empowered commanders in the Pacific to order the launch of nuclear weapons under very specific circumstances, for instance, and Kennedy and Johnson kept up the tradition. Wellerstein pointed out that DOGE employees without clearances appear to have access to classified systems that would normally be considered quite sensitive. Other things that were once forbidden might also be on the table.The clearest nuclear threat might be Musk seeing routine environmental cleanup as wokeIf President Trump decides that Elon Musk should have access to nukes, and tells the military to override their normal requirements, and the military takes that as a legal and actionable order, then why not? Wellerstein said. Its an absurd and patently idiotic and self-destructive idea, but that does not differentiate it strongly from other things presently going on. It is suicidal in nature, but so are other actions currently being undertaken under Trumps authority.The Football and Biscuit are not sacrosanct.But in even this worst-case of worst-case scenarios, theres no big red button Trump or Musk can push to open up a silo and unleash nuclear Armageddon. What the president has is authority, the State Department employee said. That authority is legal in nature. The president cant launch nuclear weapons. Doesnt have the ability. The ability is distributed across dozens of people, including the submarine crew and Missileers mentioned above any of whom could break the chain. All of these scenarios rely on the military obeying orders, Wellerstein said. I would prefer to believe that they would refuse to do so. But that would also be a difficult and extraordinary thing in and of itself. It is not a situation I would want them to be in.Trump and Musk are courting far more likely nuclear disasters than launching an intercontinental-ballistic missile. Musks DOGE crew isnt filled with the kind of people you want inside the Pentagon or DoE; employee Edward Coristine has connections to cybercriminals and operated websites in Russia. He and others would likely have never gotten security clearances if Washington were functioning normally. Yet theyre barreling along anyway. And every DOGE employee is a point of failure in a delicate system involving information related to the most powerful weapons on the planet. Theres probably a ton of personnel data that would be of interest to a foreign adversary, the State Department employee said. China and Russia would love to get information about people with security clearances. Background checks turn up information about debts, family relations, and other information that would be useful in blackmailing a government official.Nuclear weapons also produce nuclear waste. The U.S. still hasnt cleaned up waste left behind by the Manhattan Project. People are sick and dying, right now, in America because of nuclear material left behind from Americas various nuclear weapons projects. Under Biden, the Department of Energy planned to spend $8.2 billion cleaning up that Cold War-era nuclear waste. But the employee worried that DOGE and Musk would see routine environmental maintenance around nuclear weapons projects as woke.A large portion of the NNSAs budget is dedicated to environmental cleanup. I could see them thinking of this as misguided environmentalism, the employee said. I can see them just deciding to shut all that stuff down.Nuclear modernization began during the Obama administration and will play out over the next 25 years.The U.S. is currently set to spend almost $2 trillion on the project. Its going to dig new missile silos across the country, deploy updated nuclear weapons, revamp computer systems, and construct new nuclear submarines. Its a large undertaking with an enormous potential for waste, fraud, and abuse. Under any administration it needs to be scrutinized and audited. Right now, the people doing those audits are Musk and DOGE.Musk and DOGE have proven they dont care about systems put in place to keep Americans safe and protect sensitive data. Theirs is a move fast and break things philosophy. There are laws and regulations in place to keep people like them out of the halls of power and away from sensitive nuclear secrets.But.Regulations only work if people take them seriously. Laws only work if they are enforced, Wellerstein said. We are in no-mans land right now.See More:
0 Comments 0 Shares
CGShares https://cgshares.com