Lightsong Member Nov 11, 2022 9,299 View: https://youtu.be/PWnyL3C535k?si=obqcngebDnarZ0JK 25: Shin Megami Tensei 3: Nocturne 24: Breath of Fire 3 23: Golden Sun 22: Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch 21: Lost Odyssey 20: Star Ocean The Second Story 19: Bravely Default 2 18: Live A Live 17: Tales of Vesperia 16: Kingdom Hearts 2 15: Grandia 2 14: Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth 13: Xenogears 12: Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door 11: Octopath Traveler 2 10: The Legends of Heroes: Trails in the Sky 09: Pokémon Gold / Silver 08: Suikoden 2 07: Earthbound 06: Draogon Quest XI: Echoes of an Elusive Age 05: Xenoblade Chronicles 3 04: Metaphor Refantazio 03: Final Fantasy X 02: Persona 5 Royal 01: Chrono Trigger The one game per franchise rule applies here. Also: Lufia II was robbed. ROBBED!  Rosebud Two Pieces Member Apr 16, 2018 51,000 Good list   It’s Time To Go Member Dec 2, 2017 22,283 No Clair obscur expedition 33 boooo also heart gold and soul silver are better than the originals.  nsilvias Member Oct 25, 2017 29,897 no ys game lol   JazzmanZ One Winged Slayer Member Oct 25, 2017 2,997 Good good, Paper Mario TTYD   CheapJi Member Apr 24, 2018 4,116 Really solid list.   Like the hat? Member Oct 25, 2017 6,745 Pretty solid list imo. Id change a few things personally but thats part and parcel with these type of things.   ynthrepic Member Oct 25, 2017 882 FFX the only FF?   OP OP Lightsong Member Nov 11, 2022 9,299 At least they picked the correct Final Fantasy!   Euler Member Oct 27, 2017 5,787 Radiant Historia got robbed.   GameOver Member Jan 26, 2021 2,123 Surprised not to see FFVII   tapdancingFreak Member Dec 12, 2017 4,823 Charlotte, NC This is a great list. XB3 is THAT game.  OP OP Lightsong Member Nov 11, 2022 9,299 ynthrepic said: FFX the only FF? Click to expand... Click to shrink... They only picked one game per franchise.   Hero_of_the_Day Avenger Oct 27, 2017 19,711 I fully agree with number 1. Lot on the rest of that list I would call "good games", but wouldn't make my top list at all. But, whatever. As long as Chrono Trigger is where it belongs.   NSESN ▲ Legend ▲ Member Oct 25, 2017 27,567 solid list, a bit of recency bias but every list has that also xenoblade 3 getting the love it deserves  Eintopf Member Jul 8, 2018 1,116 UK ...Bravely Default 2?   drewfonse Member Oct 28, 2017 4,914 ynthrepic said: FFX the only FF? Click to expand... Click to shrink... I know right? I thought I was imagining things  ShaggsMagoo Member Oct 28, 2017 5,085 Holy shit, it's actually almost all JRPGs! I would say Kingdom Hearts and Xenoblade were arpgs, personally. Also, I'm guessing they are limiting to one per series, because there are some definitely some FF games missing otherwise.   ozumas Born to be Wise and Corrupted by Vengeance Member Dec 15, 2020 4,643 I don't think this list is good personally, specially Metaphor being number 4 and Persona 5 being considerer better than Final Fantasy X. Also doing one entry per saga is a bad idea and I don't think Chrono Trigger is the best JRPG ever, not even top 5 personally but again, this is my opinion  signal Member Oct 28, 2017 43,110 pick me list   03-AALIYAH Member Jul 21, 2023 1,339 Of course no Tengai Makyo.   mahiro_fan Member May 5, 2024 295 Metaphor at 4 is crazy. Shouldn't even be in this list.   Nyandeyanen Member Apr 16, 2024 807 That's a very strong top 3. Not sure I agree with putting Bravely Default 2 over 1 or Second though.   rzks21 Member Aug 17, 2023 3,274 No Baten Kaitos? Pathetic >:c   Anoxida Member Oct 30, 2017 3,819 Metaphor at 4?   Ashes of Dreams Fallen Guardian of Unshakable Resolve Member May 22, 2020 19,539 I feel like there is no possible way to make a list like this and have everyone agree, so it's whatever but like... Nocturne being that low is a crime. X being the only FF is bizarre. And I really don't get the hype behind Chrono Trigger. lol  u_neek Member Oct 28, 2017 1,731 ynthrepic said: FFX the only FF? Click to expand... Click to shrink... Just one title per game series, it seems.   Peerless Member Sep 10, 2018 305 For those who've played Clair Obscur, where would it rank on your top JRPG list (if you consider it one)?   Hero_of_the_Day Avenger Oct 27, 2017 19,711 Eintopf said: ...Bravely Default 2? Click to expand... Click to shrink... That one defintely got the biggest side eye from me. Like, I'm not saying it's a bad game at all. But, one of the greatest of all time? I really don't know about that.  Rinku_ Member May 4, 2023 2,195 Was the rule only one per franchise or something? Can't watch the video right now but it's not the worst list, imo Xeno 1 should be there in place of 3 but otherwise yeah I'm happy with this. Edit: FF6 robbed though imo, should be there instead of 10.  ynthrepic Member Oct 25, 2017 882 Lightsong said: They only picked one game per franchise. Click to expand... Click to shrink... That's a terrible rule for a best of genre list of any kind  OP OP Lightsong Member Nov 11, 2022 9,299 Ashes of Dreams said: X being the only FF is bizarre. Click to expand... Click to shrink... Only one per franchise, so they picked the best one: x   Soriku Member Nov 12, 2017 7,628 Where is TWEWY   Reflecting Sky Member Mar 17, 2024 2,588 Meh. Not feeling it to be honest. Too many personal favorites missing.   Banamy Member Oct 27, 2017 1,737 Pokemon black and white should be up there instead of gold and silver   ozumas Born to be Wise and Corrupted by Vengeance Member Dec 15, 2020 4,643 Peerless said: For those who've played Clair Obscur, where would it rank on your top JRPG list (if you consider it one)? Click to expand... Click to shrink... If we only count one entry per saga, top 10 surely and can be top 5 depending on the day   Aleh Member Oct 27, 2017 19,958 I hate lists.   Deluxury Member Dec 3, 2018 875 Lol at Bravely Default 2 indeed.   OP OP Lightsong Member Nov 11, 2022 9,299 ynthrepic said: That's a terrible rule for a best of genre list of any kind Click to expand... Click to shrink... I odn't know, having like 80% of your list contained of Final Fantasys, Dragon Quests and Personas would be terribly boring.   hannuraina Prophet of Truth Member Jan 7, 2018 587 a list with xenogears get a thumbs up from me. ok with chrono trigger but do prefer cross   Ashes of Dreams Fallen Guardian of Unshakable Resolve Member May 22, 2020 19,539 Lightsong said: Only one per franchise, so they picked the best one: x Click to expand... Click to shrink... Ahh, I missed that part of the OP. Okay then fair enough. X wouldn't be my pick but that's valid. Since they are counting SMT and Persona as different things though, that also means that Digital Devil Saga and Devil Survivor should be on the list though. ynthrepic said: That's a terrible rule for a best of genre list of any kind Click to expand... Click to shrink... Nah, I do it sometimes too. A Top 25 dominated by four franchises isn't as fun.  ConflictResolver Member Jan 1, 2024 4,686 Midgar No FFVII detected, list rejected.   hannuraina Prophet of Truth Member Jan 7, 2018 587 Lightsong said: I odn't know, having like 80% of your list contained of Final Fantasys, Dragon Quests and Personas would be terribly boring. Click to expand... Click to shrink... exactly   Sesha ▲ Legend ▲ Member Oct 25, 2017 10,953 No Shadow Hearts: Covenant :( Looks like they restricted it to one entry per franchise. Understandable, but makes for a lot of glaring omissions.  SnakeEater Member Oct 31, 2017 1,356 Pretty good list tbh   tapdancingFreak Member Dec 12, 2017 4,823 Charlotte, NC Peerless said: For those who've played Clair Obscur, where would it rank on your top JRPG list (if you consider it one)? Click to expand... Click to shrink... too early to tell for my personal list and I'd say for lists like this IGN one we need a five year buffer   Kito Member Nov 6, 2017 3,486 I'm shocked that Lunar wouldn't make the list.   Dougieflesh One Winged Slayer The Fallen Oct 25, 2017 37,001 Milky Way Ghetto Best Final Fantasy was chosen   N64Controller Member Nov 2, 2017 12,673 "ONE PER SERIES" rule is great for lists and should always be done. I'm not looking at ranking because Ranking is irrelevant. However ... choosing this Final Fantasy and this Trails is borderline criminal. Final Fantasy should always be a toss up between 6 and 7. Sky 2 is the best Trails game by a wide margin.  Neverx Prophet of Truth - One Winged Slayer Member Sep 17, 2020 3,830 Florida Metaphor at number 4 is crazy