[Digital Foundry] Was the rumoured Switch Pro actually Switch 2 all along?
RandomlyRandom67
Member
Jul 7, 2023
2,535
Was the rumoured Switch Pro actually Switch 2 all along?
The Switch 2's main processor has been analysed - and its design is older than you might imagine.
www.eurogamer.net
Remember the discourse surrounding a proposed Switch Pro? Rumours of an upgraded Switch model began as early as 2018, but it wasn't until 2020 that the Pro's attributes including "more computing power and 4K high definition graphics" were reported on by Bloomberg.
Simultaneously, it was understood that the Pro would also feature a seven-inch OLED panel.
Of course, the OLED upgrade happened for the original Switch but the Pro did not.
However, recent coverage of the Switch 2's main processor may provide a partial explanation.
Forensic analysis of a final Switch 2 chip by Geekerwan and Kurnal suggests that the hardware was finalised way back in 2021.
With the benefit of hindsight, it now seems plausible that the Switch Pro was an amalgamation of rumours: a combination of the Switch OLED model and formative work on the console that'll finally hit stores on June 5th this year.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
....
Even more telling is that both analyses reveal that the chip was "taped out" - basically meaning the design was complete - in 2021.
Geekerwan compares this to Nvidia's GA107 processor - another 8nm product, taped out in 2020 and released in the form of various GPUs (RTX 3050, for example) in 2021.
The implication is that Nintendo had the new Switch 2 processor ready up to four years ago and could conceivably have released a Switch successor in 2022.
Bearing in mind that processors take some time to create, it's very likely that leaks from Nintendo in Japan, or via its partners, could have started in 2020 when the Switch Pro reports began - at the same time as the platform holder was planning its OLED upgrade.
However, it wasn't until June 2021 that noted leaker kopite7kimi named the new processor as T239 and stated that it would sit at the heart of the next Nintendo console.
It seems as though the leaker got wind of the project just as T239 completed development at the taping out stage.
So, the question is why it has taken so long for Switch 2 to arrive, bearing in mind that Nintendo would have had final silicon in 2021.
Being familiar with console design having spoken to console system architects in the past, final silicon does typically arrive a year before a console releases.
Bearing in mind that T239 was ready in 2021, it would have taken years to get to that point.
Maybe an earlier Switch 2 was considered - but of course, plans can change.
At the beginning of the project, one might imagine that Nintendo would still not understand just how long-lived the original Switch would be and the extent to which the Covid pandemic would elevate its sales.
In turn, game development for the older system would continue.
In the meantime, one might imagine that the production cost for the new T239 processor would have decreased - the 8nm process is old technology now, but thanks to Nintendo and Nvidia, the production lines can still continue with a brand new console to sustain them.
The firm didn't release Switch 2 any earlier because there was no business case for doing so: the original model was still wildly popular.
Then there's the fact that development resources were still invested in the existing Switch - the transition period to Switch 2 and the need to build up enough software for a new console would obviously delay the release of the machine.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Ultimately, the controversy surrounding the make-up of the Switch 2 processor comes from a good place - the desire for the new Nintendo hardware to be the best it can be - but perhaps this idea misses the point.
Developers work with what they're given, often delivering remarkable results.
We were concerned about the Tegra X1 powering the original Switch based on its showing in the Nvidia Shield Android TV micro-console - and yet developers delivered miracles from its relatively meagre capabilities.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
SharpX68K
Member
Nov 10, 2017
11,781
Chicagoland
Oh boy.
This is gonna be one for the ages...
DC5remy
Member
Jan 20, 2018
9,751
Texas
lol.
First reply nails it
ConflictResolver
Member
Jan 1, 2024
4,726
Midgar
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Ant_17
Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,889
Greece
Yes.
tucah
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,488
maybe!
BabyDontHurtMe
Member
Dec 9, 2018
30,627
New Jersey
Wouldn't be surprised
YuriLowell
Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,477
Yes.
Jswanko
Member
Oct 26, 2017
43
ConflictResolver said:
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Ant_17 said:
tucah said:
There you have it!
yap
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
10,779
why not
OP
OP
RandomlyRandom67
Member
Jul 7, 2023
2,535
ConflictResolver said:
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I think the implication being made here is the Switch OLED and Switch 2 rumors collided to form an amalgamation rumor of a "Switch Pro." Switch Pro might have never existed, it was just the fact that a Switch OLED revision was coming while T239 was deep into design phase and presumably taped out in 2021
Homura
▲ Legend ▲
Member
Aug 20, 2019
6,940
Of course.
Leakers assumed around 2020-2021 all the T239 information was about a Pro version, not realizing Nintendo was just planning the successor all the way back then.
Kouriozan
Member
Oct 25, 2017
24,678
Oh I so wished Switch Pro was real, years and years of bad performances and I had enough, can't really fucking wait to get a Switch 2 lmao.
iirc Switch Pro rumors did start to appear around 2020, so it could line up and people mistakenly thinking Switch 2 preps was a Pro model.
Glio
Member
Oct 27, 2017
27,708
Spain
Sometimes you get a rumor wrong and that's it.
natestellar
Member
Sep 16, 2018
853
It seems to be the case.
RivalGT
Member
Dec 13, 2017
7,449
Probably not related to a switch pro, but DF is likely right.
Why release the switch 2 when switch 1 was selling amazingly well.
Source: https://www.resetera.com/threads/digital-foundry-was-the-rumoured-switch-pro-actually-switch-2-all-along.1188360/" style="color: #0066cc;">https://www.resetera.com/threads/digital-foundry-was-the-rumoured-switch-pro-actually-switch-2-all-along.1188360/
#digital #foundry #was #the #rumoured #switch #pro #actually #all #along
[Digital Foundry] Was the rumoured Switch Pro actually Switch 2 all along?
RandomlyRandom67
Member
Jul 7, 2023
2,535
Was the rumoured Switch Pro actually Switch 2 all along?
The Switch 2's main processor has been analysed - and its design is older than you might imagine.
www.eurogamer.net
Remember the discourse surrounding a proposed Switch Pro? Rumours of an upgraded Switch model began as early as 2018, but it wasn't until 2020 that the Pro's attributes including "more computing power and 4K high definition graphics" were reported on by Bloomberg.
Simultaneously, it was understood that the Pro would also feature a seven-inch OLED panel.
Of course, the OLED upgrade happened for the original Switch but the Pro did not.
However, recent coverage of the Switch 2's main processor may provide a partial explanation.
Forensic analysis of a final Switch 2 chip by Geekerwan and Kurnal suggests that the hardware was finalised way back in 2021.
With the benefit of hindsight, it now seems plausible that the Switch Pro was an amalgamation of rumours: a combination of the Switch OLED model and formative work on the console that'll finally hit stores on June 5th this year.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
....
Even more telling is that both analyses reveal that the chip was "taped out" - basically meaning the design was complete - in 2021.
Geekerwan compares this to Nvidia's GA107 processor - another 8nm product, taped out in 2020 and released in the form of various GPUs (RTX 3050, for example) in 2021.
The implication is that Nintendo had the new Switch 2 processor ready up to four years ago and could conceivably have released a Switch successor in 2022.
Bearing in mind that processors take some time to create, it's very likely that leaks from Nintendo in Japan, or via its partners, could have started in 2020 when the Switch Pro reports began - at the same time as the platform holder was planning its OLED upgrade.
However, it wasn't until June 2021 that noted leaker kopite7kimi named the new processor as T239 and stated that it would sit at the heart of the next Nintendo console.
It seems as though the leaker got wind of the project just as T239 completed development at the taping out stage.
So, the question is why it has taken so long for Switch 2 to arrive, bearing in mind that Nintendo would have had final silicon in 2021.
Being familiar with console design having spoken to console system architects in the past, final silicon does typically arrive a year before a console releases.
Bearing in mind that T239 was ready in 2021, it would have taken years to get to that point.
Maybe an earlier Switch 2 was considered - but of course, plans can change.
At the beginning of the project, one might imagine that Nintendo would still not understand just how long-lived the original Switch would be and the extent to which the Covid pandemic would elevate its sales.
In turn, game development for the older system would continue.
In the meantime, one might imagine that the production cost for the new T239 processor would have decreased - the 8nm process is old technology now, but thanks to Nintendo and Nvidia, the production lines can still continue with a brand new console to sustain them.
The firm didn't release Switch 2 any earlier because there was no business case for doing so: the original model was still wildly popular.
Then there's the fact that development resources were still invested in the existing Switch - the transition period to Switch 2 and the need to build up enough software for a new console would obviously delay the release of the machine.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Ultimately, the controversy surrounding the make-up of the Switch 2 processor comes from a good place - the desire for the new Nintendo hardware to be the best it can be - but perhaps this idea misses the point.
Developers work with what they're given, often delivering remarkable results.
We were concerned about the Tegra X1 powering the original Switch based on its showing in the Nvidia Shield Android TV micro-console - and yet developers delivered miracles from its relatively meagre capabilities.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
SharpX68K
Member
Nov 10, 2017
11,781
Chicagoland
Oh boy.
This is gonna be one for the ages...
DC5remy
Member
Jan 20, 2018
9,751
Texas
lol.
First reply nails it
ConflictResolver
Member
Jan 1, 2024
4,726
Midgar
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Ant_17
Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,889
Greece
Yes.
tucah
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,488
maybe!
BabyDontHurtMe
Member
Dec 9, 2018
30,627
New Jersey
Wouldn't be surprised
YuriLowell
Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,477
Yes.
Jswanko
Member
Oct 26, 2017
43
ConflictResolver said:
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Ant_17 said:
tucah said:
There you have it!
yap
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
10,779
why not
OP
OP
RandomlyRandom67
Member
Jul 7, 2023
2,535
ConflictResolver said:
No they cancelled Pro because of Covid.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I think the implication being made here is the Switch OLED and Switch 2 rumors collided to form an amalgamation rumor of a "Switch Pro." Switch Pro might have never existed, it was just the fact that a Switch OLED revision was coming while T239 was deep into design phase and presumably taped out in 2021
Homura
▲ Legend ▲
Member
Aug 20, 2019
6,940
Of course.
Leakers assumed around 2020-2021 all the T239 information was about a Pro version, not realizing Nintendo was just planning the successor all the way back then.
Kouriozan
Member
Oct 25, 2017
24,678
Oh I so wished Switch Pro was real, years and years of bad performances and I had enough, can't really fucking wait to get a Switch 2 lmao.
iirc Switch Pro rumors did start to appear around 2020, so it could line up and people mistakenly thinking Switch 2 preps was a Pro model.
Glio
Member
Oct 27, 2017
27,708
Spain
Sometimes you get a rumor wrong and that's it.
natestellar
Member
Sep 16, 2018
853
It seems to be the case.
RivalGT
Member
Dec 13, 2017
7,449
Probably not related to a switch pro, but DF is likely right.
Why release the switch 2 when switch 1 was selling amazingly well.
Source: https://www.resetera.com/threads/digital-foundry-was-the-rumoured-switch-pro-actually-switch-2-all-along.1188360/
#digital #foundry #was #the #rumoured #switch #pro #actually #all #along
·40 Ansichten