arstechnica.com
WAGON! WAGON! WAGON! The 2025 BMW M5 Touring review: Way more power, way too much weight BMW has been making M5s for 40 years, but the latest one has lost its way somewhat. Bradley Iger Mar 31, 2025 1:04 pm | 26 At long last, BMW has brought the M5 Touring to the US. But does the latest M5 match up to the previous iterations? Credit: Bradley Iger At long last, BMW has brought the M5 Touring to the US. But does the latest M5 match up to the previous iterations? Credit: Bradley Iger Story textSizeSmallStandardLargeWidth *StandardWideLinksStandardOrange* Subscribers only Learn moreWhen BMW introduced the original M5 to the European motoring public in 1984, the automaker effectively established a new vehicle segment. By combining the practical and understatedly rakish E28 5-Series with the motorsport-derived six-cylinder engine from the M1 supercar, the automaker had created a do-it-all performance machine, a vehicle that could serve as a tasteful and luxurious sedan one moment and a charismatic sports car the next.Its a concept that has guided the development of not only subsequent generations of the M5 but also all of the other sports sedans that have dared to go toe to toe with it over the past forty years. For decades, its been the benchmark by which all big, fast four-doors have been judged, but after spending a week with the all-new $125,275 G99-generation M5 Touring, I cant help but wonder if that era is coming to a close.A range of factors have contributed to this seismic shift. While other automakers have been chasing the M5s ghost around the Nrburgring, BMW has purposely started to reposition its M Division vehicles as the pinnacle representation of the brand rather than the pinnacle representation of BMW performance. Its a move that has yielded models like the XM, a vehicle that certainly has plenty of firepower under the hood but ultimately prioritizes style over substance. The iconic sport sedan badge returns with a burly hybrid powertrain and an array of high-tech hardware designed to mask its substantial heft, but the end result has me longing for the past. Bradley Iger The iconic sport sedan badge returns with a burly hybrid powertrain and an array of high-tech hardware designed to mask its substantial heft, but the end result has me longing for the past. Bradley Iger Practical but heavy. Bradley Iger Practical but heavy. Bradley Iger The iconic sport sedan badge returns with a burly hybrid powertrain and an array of high-tech hardware designed to mask its substantial heft, but the end result has me longing for the past. Bradley Iger Practical but heavy. Bradley Iger And as BMW contends with customers undying thirst for more, it must also contend with an array of European regulations aimed at quelling everything from emissions to road noise. From an engineering standpoint, this creates a significant challenge: How do you make your new sports sedan more capable and engaging than the last one while still adhering to the rule of law? For BMW, the answer appears to come in the form of a vast array of technologies aimed at convincing you that the experience is more thrilling than it actually is.I dont mean to imply that the new M5 is a bad car, or even bad at executing the mission of an M5. In some respects, theres cause for celebration: For the first time in the M5s history, the Touring model has made its way stateside to do battle with the RS 6 Avant, Audis high-performance wagon. Opting for the longroof not only scores you an arguably more stylish M5; it also expands its cargo capacity to a crossover-like 57.6 cubic feet (1,631 L) with the rear seats down.But the pursuit of more seems to have been a core priority during the development of the new M5, and more doesnt always equate to a better automobile. Credit: Bradley Iger For example, theres quite a bit more power on tap than in the outgoing M5. Under the hood is a 4.4 L twin-turbocharged V8 that dishes out 577 hp (430 kW) and 553 lb-ft (750 Nm) of torque, and for the first time in an M5, its paired up with a permanently excited synchronous electric motor thats integrated into the eight-speed transmission.The electric motor can deliver up to 194 hp (145 kW) and 207 lb-ft (280 Nm) on its own, and with a 14.8 kWh battery pack onboard, it can provide roughly 25 miles (40 km) of all-electric range. All in, the M Hybrid powertrain delivers a grand total of 717 hp (535 kW) and 738 lb-ft (1,000 Nm) of torque to all four wheels.But while gains of 100 hp (75 kW) and 185 lb-ft (250 Nm) over the outgoing M5 Competition are substantial, they come at a significant cost to the M5s curb weight. Now tipping the scales at an almost unbelievable 5,400 lbs (2,449 kg), the latest M5 weighs roughly a thousand pounds more than the outgoing model and is actually heavier than its all-electric counterpart, the i5. That equates to an M5 with a power-to-weight ratio thats worse than its predecessors, along with an official 060 mph time that, at a still furiously quick 3.4 seconds, is two-tenths slower.The hybrid system isnt entirely to blame for the additional heft, though. The latest M5 has also grown in proportion by more than four inches (101 mm) in length and two and a half inches (63 mm) in width. With flared fenders, huge air intakes, and a hunkered-down stance, it gives the M5 significant visual presence on the road, but behind the wheel, it sometimes feels more like youre driving a low-slung SUV than a svelte sports sedan. Credit: Bradley Iger M5-specific front seats, unique lighting treatments, and a flat-bottomed steering wheel with chunky paddle shifters and a pair of bright red M buttons bring a sense of occasion to the cabin, but its the 14.9-inch touchscreen infotainment display that will capture the majority of drivers attention. As weve seen in other recent BMW models, were left with only a small collection of capacitive buttons, a rotary knob, and (mercifully) a volume dial on the center console.Basic functions like adjusting the fan speed of the air conditioning system require taking your attention off of the road to call up the comfort settings on the display, and if you dare to venture further down the rabbit hole to adjust something else, youll find an app drawer-style menu filled with ambiguously named icons that rarely get you where you want to go the first time out.Do I change the damper stiffness by pressing the M Mode button on the center console, or is it in the Drivetrain and chassis submenu under Driving Settings? The answer is neither. (In fact, you should use iDrives excellent voice commands so you can keep your hands on the wheel and your eyes on the roadEd.)With adjustments for throttle response, brake regeneration, steering weight, brake pedal responsiveness, transmission behavior, all-wheel drive system modes, simulated engine noise volume, and other performance-related features, you can create literally hundreds of different combinations of vehicle settings, but thankfully, the aforementioned M1 and M2 buttons on the steering wheel provide an easy way to call up one of your two favorite presets on the fly. The bigger concern, though, is how all of these augmentations and enhancements seem to conspire to hide the shortcomings of BMWs design decisions but arent successful in doing so. This will be the last generation of BMW iDrive to use a rotary controller, and we'll miss it. Bradley Iger This will be the last generation of BMW iDrive to use a rotary controller, and we'll miss it. Bradley Iger CarPlay is present and correct. And not at an additional upcharge. Bradley Iger CarPlay is present and correct. And not at an additional upcharge. Bradley Iger This will be the last generation of BMW iDrive to use a rotary controller, and we'll miss it. Bradley Iger CarPlay is present and correct. And not at an additional upcharge. Bradley Iger Chassis upgrades are a prerequisite for an M car, and with an M-tuned adaptative suspension, additional structural bracing, massive brake discs with six-piston calipers up front, four-wheel steering, and torque vectoring all on board as standard, the M5 certainly isnt short on them. Given that, its reasonable to expect that an M model will have a firmer ride quality than its garden-variety counterpart.But the vehicle has an additional measure of harshness as compared to previous M5 models, even under normal driving situations with the dampers set to their most relaxed mode, which I theorize is related to the suspension tuning needed to keep body motions controlled and maintain a sport-oriented feel despite the weight involved.Dont get me wrong, this is still a grand tourer of the highest order. Triple-digit speeds can be accessed with a brief stab of the throttle, and thanks to the improved ergonomics of the latest 5-Series and the model-specific sport seats that are both comfortable and supportive, the M5 will still devour highway miles with the best of them. At times when both the electric motor and the V8 are working together, the hybridized powertrain also delivers the kind of instant-on throttle response thats typically reserved for EVs.The realities of physics become harder to ignore when the going gets twisty, though. BMW engineers deserve significant praise for making a vehicle that weighs the better part of three tons handle the way this M5 does, but the car still feels burdened by the additional heft.Even when the array of settings youve chosen indicate that youre ready to roll out of pit lane at Laguna Seca, the steering remains devoid of feedback, mid-corner bumps often result in multiple suspension oscillations before the car fully regains its composure, and the pads that are equipped with optional carbon ceramic brakes get hot enough to smell after just a few minutes of hustling through the canyons. And despite the fact that the M5s various enhancements and augmentations assure you that this spirited drive is going swimmingly, the M2youre chasing down your favorite backroad continues to fade into the distance. Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger Bradley Iger The M5 seats are easier to get in and out of than the carbon buckets in the M5 CS we tested. Bradley Iger The M5 seats are easier to get in and out of than the carbon buckets in the M5 CS we tested. Bradley Iger The M5's back seats. Bradley Iger The M5's back seats. Bradley Iger The M5 seats are easier to get in and out of than the carbon buckets in the M5 CS we tested. Bradley Iger The M5's back seats. Bradley Iger One could argue that these compromises are unavoidable in the pursuit of more, and in this rapidly evolving automotive landscape, progress can be quantified in a number of different ways. But if youre the kind of enthusiast who values the driving experience over the figures on the spec sheet, you might actually find yourself wishing for less. 26 Comments