RIAS warns of tragedy over tech hub plans for Mackintoshs Lighthouse
www.architectsjournal.co.uk
The centre in Mitchell Lane, which opened in 1999 and is run by Glasgow City Council (GCC), shut its doors during the pandemic and has only been open to the public on a handful of occasions since.Now, a possible operator has emerged to take over the running of the former Glasgow Herald building (1895), designed by Charles Rennie Mackintosh and refurbished by Page\Park 26 years ago.However, the new plans, which have been put to Glasgow City Councils Contracts and Property Committee, do not include the retention of the National Architecture Centre within the building.AdvertisementUnder the proposals, Scottish start-up Sustainable Ventures would lease the Lighthouse from the local authority to create a Net Zero Innovation Hub to support local SMEs, council papers said. That would see public access restored for education focusing on the renewable energy sector.RIAS president Karen Anderson said that, while she welcomed the plans to give this important historical building [a] long-term future, the loss of the dedicated centre for architecture, urban design, and regeneration would be a tragedy for Scotland.Anderson continued: In these hugely challenging times for Scotlands cities and towns, and in the face of the climate emergency and economic turbulence, such spaces are important in bringing the public and professionals together to address the challenges of regenerating cities and historic buildings.The lessons from the ambitious, but ultimately abandoned, Lighthouse project should be learned by the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council alike, as part of efforts to refresh architecture, planning, and regeneration policy in Scotland. As ever the RIAS stands ready to assist those endeavours.Advertising the Lighthouse on Glasgows Buchanan StreetReports of the potential reopening of the Lighthouse first emerged earlier this month. The council told the AJ at the time that it could not confirm during these confidential discussions whether the architecture centre would be kept.AdvertisementEarlier this month a council spokesperson confirmed that the Lighthouse currently remained closed to the public because the local authoritys budget did not enable the building to be staffed to accommodate members of the public.However, they added that there were still some commercial tenants in the building who had access as part of their lease agreements.Paul Sweeney, Labour Glasgow MSP, argued that the Lighthouses introverted and esoteric curation as a centre for architecture and design, rather than the use itself, had been barrier to its use over time, saying: Often its exhibits only really appealed to a professional audience, so it failed to attract significant visitor numbers.He added: The Lighthouse is one of Glasgows most iconic buildings with unrivalled views of the city centre [but] It has been deeply disappointing that Glasgow City Council hasn't reopened the much-loved building since the pandemic.With the Glasgow School of Art restoration still in limbo and the Martyrs School in Townhead now up for sale [both by Mackintosh], it's hard not to wonder if Glasgow risks squandering its greatest architectural legacy. It would be my preference to see the council seek a long-term lease rather than sell the Lighthouse.Glasgow City Council will vote on the future use of the Lighthouse on 6 February.The council has been contacted for comment.Gareth Hoskins Architects: People and Place exhibition, pictured here at The Lighthouse, Glasgow in 2008Comment:Paul Sweeney, Labour MSPOne of the main problems with the Lighthouse was ultimately its rather introverted and esoteric curation as a centre for architecture and design, rather than the use itself. Often its exhibits only really appealed to a professional audience so it failed to attract significant visitor numbers. Similar centres have been better curated and appealed to a wider audience I think a more popularly curated space focusing on Glasgows architectural history as well as being a public forum to immersively view the city model (The 3D model of Glasgow which can be used to plot major developments, identify flood risk and respond to incidents Glasgow Live) and engage with current planning applications could be a more useful way to maintain the public space, even if part of the building is to be let out for commercial purpose. Glasgows version of the London Centre could be a great success.I also hope that the wonderfully playful signage by Javier Mariscal is maintained: see Light touch for the Lighthouse in Design Week.My ultimate dream for the building is to turn it into Glasgows version of Hamburgs Miniatur Wunderland by inviting all the countrys model rail enthusiasts to build a permanent exhibition space on its floorplates.Malcom Fraser, Fraser/Livingstone ArchitectsScotlands Policy on Architecture has long been to booster a glam, publicly-supported and insulararent we wonderfulexceptionalism while actively undermining the conditions that allow good architecture to flourish PPP and its derivatives, Procurement Hell and affordable housing now led by Mass Housebuilders. Most telling is how the formal adoption of the proudly-proclaimed Worlds First National Policy on Architecture around the turn of the century almost exactly coincided with the near-strangulation of the emergence of vigorous new Scottish practices a few wonderful ones have appeared but they are swimming against the tide.The Lighthouse was, at its worst, a displacement activity: our built environment input is severely curtailed, but heres a nice exhibition to sink all our love and care, time and effort into. Its loss is a simple reflection of the huge disconnect between boosterism and reality. For me, a commercial tech hub is a fine use of this physically introverted site Paul Sweeny is right, what Glasgow needs is a much simpler, public-facing shop window for a big 3d model; and what Scotland needs is policy that allows architects to be at the table, to tackle the carbon, housing and public building crises we face.
0 Комментарии
·0 Поделились
·35 Просмотры